COINCRYPTO24

Peraire-Bueno Brothers Acquitted in $25M Ethereum MEV Exploit Case

Judge Jessica Clarke acquitted the Peraire-Bueno brothers on 16 November 2026, finding no proof of the misrepresentations wire fraud requires in the April 2023 MEV-Boost exploit case.

Crypto Support Desk
Crypto Support Desk

Crypto Support & Research Desk

Published Nov 17, 2026
Updated Nov 17, 2026
8 min read
Referenced Assets:General Market
Share:

Quick answer: A federal judge in Manhattan acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno on Monday, 16 November 2026, ending the US case over a roughly $25 million Ethereum MEV exploit from April 2023. Judge Jessica Clarke found prosecutors had not shown the material misrepresentations wire fraud requires, after a 2025 trial ended in a hung jury.

What the judge decided on 16 November

On Monday, 16 November 2026, US District Judge Jessica Clarke of the Southern District of New York granted a motion for acquittal filed by Anton Peraire-Bueno and James Peraire-Bueno, the MIT-educated brothers accused of exploiting Ethereum's block-building pipeline in April 2023. The Block reported the ruling the same afternoon.

According to the reports available so far, the judge concluded that prosecutors had failed to show the kind of material misrepresentation that a wire fraud conviction requires. She also noted that the trades did not take place on a regulated market whose rules prohibited the conduct at issue. Reports paraphrase her as saying the court was not deciding whether the brothers acted immorally or unethically, or whether they committed some other, uncharged offence, only whether the evidence supported wire fraud.

The full written opinion had not been widely circulated at the time of writing, so the reasoning above is based on news coverage rather than the ruling text. We will update this article if the opinion adds material detail.

What the brothers were accused of

The case centred on maximal extractable value (MEV), the profit a block producer or searcher can capture by choosing which transactions go into a block and in what order. After Ethereum moved to proof of stake in September 2022, most validators began outsourcing block construction through MEV-Boost, software that lets validators accept blocks built by specialised builders via relays.

Prosecutors alleged that in April 2023, about seven months after the Merge, the brothers:

  • Set up validators so they could propose blocks themselves.
  • Broadcast "bait" transactions designed to attract sandwich bots, automated traders that front-run and back-run other users' swaps.
  • Exploited a flaw in how a MEV-Boost relay released block contents, letting them see and reorder the bots' bundled trades before the block was final.
  • Replaced the bots' trades with their own, draining roughly $25 million in about 12 seconds.

According to statements made by prosecutors at a March 2026 hearing, reported by DL News, Flashbots patched the relay bug within about 24 hours.

The brothers were arrested and indicted in May 2024. The charges reported across outlets were conspiracy to commit wire fraud, wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering; some outlets also list receipt of stolen property.

How the case reached an acquittal

The 2025 trial and mistrial

The first trial ran for about four weeks in late 2025. In November 2025 the judge declared a mistrial after the jury deadlocked. As The Block reported at the time, the jurors' disagreement was about how to apply the law to the facts rather than about what had happened on-chain.

Prosecutors then said they wanted a retrial in early 2026.

The March 2026 hearing

On Friday, 13 March 2026, the defence argued before Judge Clarke that the brothers should be acquitted outright. They leaned on the earlier acquittal of Avraham Eisenberg in the Mango Markets case, another prosecution in which a court found that exploiting a protocol's rules did not by itself amount to fraud. The judge said she would decide that motion before addressing a retrial. Monday's ruling granted it.

Why the ruling matters for Ethereum and DeFi users

A limit on stretching wire fraud to code exploits

Wire fraud needs a scheme to obtain money through false or fraudulent representations. The defence argued, and the court appears to have accepted, that sending valid transactions that a protocol accepts is not the same as lying to a counterparty. That is the same fault line seen in the Mango Markets case.

For the crypto industry, the result narrows one route prosecutors have used against on-chain exploits: treating aggressive or deceptive trading against automated systems as a misrepresentation to a person. Coin Center's Peter Van Valkenburgh had called the prosecution a "massive overstep", and policy groups are likely to cite this ruling in future cases.

What it does not mean

  • It is not a ruling that MEV exploits are legal in general. Reports say the judge explicitly declined to decide whether other, uncharged laws could apply.
  • It does not change civil liability. Parties who lost money can still pursue civil claims where available.
  • It does not change Ethereum's protocol. The relay bug at the centre of the case was patched in 2023, and validators running current MEV-Boost and relay software are not affected by that specific flaw.

For context on how fragile market structure and liquidity can amplify losses, see our explainer on crypto market structure basics.

What Ethereum users and traders should take from it

Most readers never run a sandwich bot or a validator. But the case is a reminder of how the transaction pipeline works and where users can protect themselves.

1. Understand MEV exposure on swaps. Large swaps with high slippage tolerance are the trades sandwich bots target. Keep slippage settings tight and split very large orders.

2. Use private transaction routing where your wallet supports it. Many wallets and DEX front-ends offer "MEV protection" or private RPC endpoints that keep a swap out of the public mempool until it is included.

3. Check what you are signing. No legitimate MEV-protection service needs your seed phrase. Treat any site asking for it as a scam.

4. Watch the price context. MEV losses are larger in volatile markets. Ether's recent drop, covered in our piece on ETH falling to $1,711, is the kind of environment where slippage and sandwich losses grow.

5. Treat "recovery" offers with suspicion. High-profile rulings often bring scammers claiming they can recover MEV or exploit losses for a fee. Courts and official agencies do not cold-call victims through social media.

How this fits the wider regulatory picture

The acquittal lands during a busy period for US crypto enforcement and market rules. Prediction markets are being fought over at state and federal level, as covered in our report on Louisiana's ban and the CFTC lawsuit, and Congress is looking at officials' trading in our coverage of the House Oversight memo on prediction markets.

Taken together, courts are drawing sharper lines between conduct that may be unfair or exploitative and conduct that fits the specific elements of a federal crime. Lawmakers may respond by writing crypto-specific market manipulation rules rather than relying on older fraud statutes.

What to watch next

  • The written opinion. Its exact reasoning will matter more to future cases than the headline.
  • Any government response. Whether prosecutors comment on, or seek to challenge, the outcome.
  • Civil cases. Whether any of the affected bot operators pursue civil recovery.
  • Industry reaction. Builders, relays and MEV researchers may publish their own analyses of what the ruling means for searchers.

Frequently asked questions

Who are the Peraire-Bueno brothers?

Anton and James Peraire-Bueno are MIT graduates who were charged in May 2024 over an April 2023 exploit of Ethereum MEV-Boost that prosecutors said took about $25 million from trading bots.

Why were they acquitted?

According to reports of the 16 November 2026 ruling, Judge Jessica Clarke found prosecutors did not prove the material misrepresentations required for wire fraud, and noted the trades were not on a regulated market with rules banning the conduct.

Does the ruling make MEV exploits legal?

No. Reports say the judge said she was not deciding whether the conduct was ethical or violated other, uncharged laws. Civil claims may also still be possible.

Was the MEV-Boost bug fixed?

Yes. Prosecutors said at a March 2026 hearing that Flashbots patched the relay flaw within about 24 hours of the April 2023 incident.

How can I reduce MEV losses on my own swaps?

Keep slippage tolerance tight, split large trades, and use a wallet or DEX option that routes transactions privately. Never share your seed phrase with any service.

Conclusion

The Peraire-Bueno acquittal ends a closely watched case over a 12-second, $25 million Ethereum MEV exploit, and adds to a line of rulings that limit how far wire fraud law stretches to on-chain conduct. It is not a green light for exploits, and the written opinion will decide how much weight it carries. For everyday users, the practical lesson is unchanged: tighten slippage, route large swaps privately, and ignore anyone offering paid "recovery".

This article is for information only and is not legal, financial or investment advice. Coin Crypto 24 is an independent publication and is not affiliated with any exchange, protocol or party to this case. We never ask for seed phrases, private keys, passwords or 2FA codes.

Regulatory & Financial Risk Disclosure

The opinions, research, and analysis expressed in this publication are solely for educational and informational purposes and do not constitute investment, financial, legal, or tax advice. Digital asset markets are speculative and volatile. Past performance does not indicate future results. Always perform independent due diligence.

About the Author

Crypto Support Desk
Crypto Support Desk

Crypto Support & Research Desk

Crypto Support Desk publishes practical, source-led guides to exchange, wallet, network and on-chain service changes. Information is checked against primary or reputable security sources and is not investment advice.

Source-led crypto support research